For Faculty
Please consult the SMD Regulations of the Faculty for information about:
- An overview, including general principles and premises for our promotions and tenure system
- Criteria for academic appointments, promotion, and tenure
- Procedures for faculty appointments and promotions
- Additional issues including appeals, compensation, vacation, consulting policy, racial and sexual harassment, and disability
- A summary of time in rank guidelines
- Guidelines with examples of application of the criteria for promotion
- Curriculum vitae format
- Family leave policy and procedures for extending the 'academic clock'
- Academic clock adjustment for part-time faculty
Processes for Faculty Appointments and Promotions
Overview
All as specified in the SMD Regulations of the Faculty
All requests for appointments, reappointments, promotions, and decisions for tenure originate at the departmental level, not from the Dean’s Office
All appointments, reappointments, and promotions at the rank of Associate Professor and above require Steering Committee processes (as advisory to the Dean’s Office) and approval of the University Board of Trustees
All appointments, reappointments, and promotions at the rank of Assistant Professor and below require approval of the Dean’s Office (but do not require Steering Committee processes)
The Steering Committee of MEDSAC serves as the School-wide promotions committee, making decisions on behalf of the Dean
- Chaired by the Vice Dean for Academic Affairs (VDAA)
- Consists of 18 members serving three-year terms
- Rather than replace the entire committee all at once every three years, members’ terms are staggered so each year six members rotate off, replaced by six new members, to ensure consistency of committee decisions over the years
- All members hold academic appointments at the rank of Professor
- Approximately half of the members are Chairs or Center Directors
- Approximately half of the members are from basic science areas, the other half from clinical areas
- Members of Steering chair all faculty ad hoc committees, helping ensure that our promotions criteria are applied consistently
Types of Faculty Appointments
Academic appointments (e.g., Assistant Professor, Associate Professor, Professor): activities that include Teaching plus at least one of the following components: Research, Scholarship, Institutional Scholarship, Clinical
Research appointments (e.g., Research Assistant Professor): expectations are solely for research activities, with appointments contingent on funding
Professional appointments (e.g., Assistant Professor of Clinical): expectations are solely for clinical or other professional services, and may contribute significantly to teaching
Voluntary clinical appointments (e.g., Clinical Assistant Professor): typically community-based, non-salaried faculty members involved in teaching or other activities at the SMD
Other / special appointments include non-doctoral-level appointments, Adjunct, Visiting, Interim, and Emeritus faculty members
Appointments, Re-appointments and Promotions
Appointments, Reappointments, Promotions
Materials as in the Required Paperwork are uploaded in Box for submission to the Office of Academic Affairs
Departments initiate the process for appointments, reappointments, and promotions at all ranks. In smaller departments, actions may be initiated by the chair; larger departments may utilize an intradepartmental promotions committee, division chiefs, or other internal processes.
Faculty appointments at all ranks require review by SMD finance and/or hospital leadership and/or URMFG as appropriate.
Actions for ranks at Assistant Professor and below level
- Reviewed and approved by the VDAA.
Actions for ranks at the Associate Professor level and above
- Reviewed by the VDAA and the Steering Committee (reappointments) or initiates the ad hoc process (initial appointments, promotions).
Following approval of an appointment or reappointment, faculty are sent a confirmation letter with a copy to the Chair and (if relevant) Center Director.
The Office of Academic Affairs will work with faculty members to prepare applications for the approval of the University Provost.
Please review the two forms below before you start preparing your proposal:
All proposals are to be submitted by email to the Senior Associate Dean for Academic Affairs, either as a Word Document or electronically converted to a PDF (using “print to PDF” on a Mac, or Adobe on Windows). Please do not simply scan your proposal to a PDF, as doing so makes it impossible to select/copy text from the PDF. The Academic Leave of Absence Information Form is a writeable pdf and may be digitally signed, or you may print the form, fill in by hand with signatures, and email a scanned copy.
Once you have returned from your leave, please submit a Post-Leave report by email to the Senior Associate Dean for Academic Affairs, either as a Word Document or electronically converted to a PDF (using “print to PDF” on a Mac, or Adobe on Windows).
Conflict of Interest Advisory Group (CIAG):
CIAG is a long standing committee charged with the oversight of conflict of interest matters for the School. As prescribed in our Faculty Conflict of Interest Policy, each school Dean must ensure compliance with this policy. It is CIAG’s responsibility to review potential conflicts of interest and to make recommendations to Dean Linehan on conflict mitigation and management.
Links are provided to resources that you may find helpful regarding relationships with industry and management of financial disclosures and potential conflicts of interest.
The majority of relevant policies are available through the UR Office of Research and Project Administration: rochester.edu/orpa
We strongly encourage you to complete the survey from a URMC-based workstation; connections from other locations will require you to VPN in to the URMC network. Once you access the site, you will need to use your URMC email/network login to access the survey.
URMC Reporting of financial disclosures (annual survey plus 30-day updates) is done through the following survey site: coi.urmc-sh.rochester.edu
FAQs About New COI Policies faq-coi.pdf
2016 update: Practical Guidance regarding the Open Payments/Sunshine Act (old, contains some outdated links)
Tip Sheet to navigate through the Open Payments data review process:
- Tips for Open Payments Registration and Review
- Open Payments Overview for Physicians - Sunshine Act Working Group
Other relevant policies of note
- Conflict of Interest Advisory Group guidelines for clinical trials in URMC
- URMC Industry Interactions Policy
- UR Purchasing COI policy
- URMC Code of Conduct
- UR Intellectual Property Policies
- UR Faculty Consulting Guidance: N.B. — outside clinical work is not allowed under the consulting policy; as per the SMD clinician compensation plan, patient care must be done through the UR Medical Faculty Group for all full-time and most part-time employed faculty members.
Start a new morning habit with faculty@urmc, an email news stream designed by faculty and for faculty. Each Tuesday and Thursday at 5:30 a.m. you'll receive one convenient email with short updates on:
- News specific to clinical, research, and education operations
- Events, lectures, CMEs
- Training opportunities
- Institutional news
- Faculty accomplishments
- Strategic Initiatives
With an easy-to-scan format and a succinct, just-the-facts style, faculty@urmc is serving up a go-to resource for all your faculty news.
For archived issues of faculty@urmc, click on the link below:
- faculty@urmc (intranet site only—available while connected to the URMC network)
For faculty departing URMC, the following are available:
- Departure form
- Optional departure survey/interview opportunity
- Resources and FAQ
- Allows consistent notification of faculty departure.
- Part of the SMD required paperwork for faculty (see SMD Required paperwork, page 29).
- Departing faculty complete, sign and return to their primary appointment department.
- Department uploads the departure form/other documents to their designated department Box folder with OAA.
Exit Survey and Exit Interview Opportunity
- On-line confidential survey and a voluntary 1:1exit interview are available for faculty departing URMC.
- When completing the departure form, faculty may choose to participate in the Exit Survey and/or an interview.
- In-person interviews will take approximately 30-45 minutes.
- When the departure form is received by the Office of Academic Affairs, faculty who elect to have an exit interview will be contacted to schedule a date and time.
___________________________________________________________________
Q: Are there resources available regarding finding another job, preparing my CV or job interview skills?
A: Please see the Office of Faculty Development website.
Q: How much advance notice should faculty provide when departing?
A: The more advance notice the better. The SMD Regulations of the Faculty ask that faculty give sufficient notice to ensure that their responsibilities can be properly covered after their departure. For specific notification requirements, review the section of the SMD Regulations relevant to your appointment, and review the language in your initial job offer letter or any subsequent letters or contracts,which also may stipulate the advance notice period required.
Q: What happens to my benefits when I leave?
A: We recommend you contact the Office of Human Resources.
Q: Will I get paid for unused vacation time?
A: Faculty do not receive a payout for unused vacation time.
Q: Can accrued vacation be used at the end of employment, that is, stop working before the end of my employment at UR?
A: Faculty may only use vacation time at the end of their employment with explicit permission of their department chair.
Q: What do I need to turn in before I leave?
A: Please review this with the appropriate administrative staff person in your department. This generally will include your UR ID card, keys, and any other UR-owned property (such as computers purchased with UR funds).
- Clinicians must return any paper charts or other records kept on patients seen as part of your UR employment; you must return these before you depart.
- Funded investigators should work with their department administrator, chair or chair designee, ORPA-assigned administrator and any funding agencies to plan for the close-out and subsequent transfer of grants or contracts.
- Other research-related issues may include coordination with your new institution of transfers of grants, the disposition of equipment, protocols, requirements, record retention, material transfer agreements, or intellectual property, and discussion with the RSRB and UCAR regarding human subject and animal use approvals/closeouts and the disposition of data deriving from human or animal research.
Q: What else do I need to do before I leave?
A: Discuss any remaining departure actions with your department chair/administrator. Faculty departure conversations should include consideration of future plans for personnel in your area (staff, trainees, faculty colleagues), and for supervisory, teaching and administrative roles.
Faculty Information Form
- If you are new faculty, click on the Faculty Information Form, complete all information and submit.
Thank you for being a member of our voluntary clinical faculty! You have joined a community of approximately 1100 professionals who, despite being busy in clinical practice or other environments, volunteer their time to support the teaching, research, and/or clinical missions of the University of Rochester School of Medicine & Dentistry. Your time and effort in support of our missions is greatly appreciated.
Here are a few FAQs about voluntary clinical faculty appointments:
Q: What titles are used to denote voluntary clinical faculty?
A: At our School, all voluntary faculty appointments are preceded by the term "Clinical," with ranks from Instructor through Professor. Thus a typical title would take the form of, for example, "Clinical Assistant Professor of Pediatrics." (Please note the difference compared with a title such as "Assistant Professor of Clinical Pediatrics," the latter being an example of a professional appointment, that is, a UR-employed faculty member whose principal responsibilities are in patient care.)
Q: Who decides whether I get my voluntary faculty appointment established or renewed? Who decides if I can be promoted in rank?
A: While the Office of Academic Affairs processes all faculty appointments, all appointments and promotions originate as proposals to the Dean's Office from the various departments of the medical school It is therefore up to the chair of your home department to determine whether someone's contributions are consistent with that department's expectations for a voluntary faculty appointment, and at what rank. We are always glad to answer general questions, but will refer you to your department chair office for more specific questions about such expectations or about the internal department processing of your faculty appointment, reappointment, or promotion in rank.
More senior faculty ranks (e.g., Clinical Associate Professor, Clinical Professor) require approval of the school-wide promotions committee ("Steering Committee") and the University of Rochester Board of Trustees, again based on proposals originating from the department chair.
Q: Are there any "perks" that come with my voluntary faculty appointment?
A: We of course hope that the teaching or other contributions you offer are personally rewarding to you in and of themselves! But, yes, there may be additional things you can gain. At your request and at your primary department's discretion, you may be given:
- A UR ID, giving you access to the University of Rochester and URMC premises
- A URMC email address, generally taking the form of FirstName_LastName@urmc.rochester.edu. This gives you a secure email account on the URMC Exchange email server.
- The ability to login to the URMC network while offsite using VPN (Virtual Private Networking). This may give you access to web resources kept securely behind the URMC firewall, including:
- The URMC Intranet
- Miner digital library, with online access to a wide range of licensed reference and reading materials. (N.B. – your UR ID card also gives you physical access to the Miner Library and its hard copy resources.)
- Having a role at the medical school, and a ".edu" email address, may allow you to access educator discounts offered by a number of companies, including software products from Microsoft and Adobe, and hardware and software products from Apple; many such products and discounts are also available to faculty through the UR Tech Store
Q: What CME/educational activities are available to me as a voluntary clinical faculty member?
A:
- You are able to attend departmental Grand Rounds and the majority of other, free, regular clinical and scientific conferences and presentations at URMC
- Access to CEL Activities
- Some conferences may offer reduced fees to faculty, at the discretion of the conference activity director
- For example, the annual Health Professions Faculty Development Colloquium is offered at no charge to UR faculty and staff
Q: Do the URMC conflict of interest policies apply to me?
A: The URMC policy on interactions with industry applies to voluntary clinical faculty when on URMC premises or conducting activities on behalf of URMC, such as teaching URMC trainees in one's clinical practice. You may familiarize yourself with URMC policies collated in the above 'Conflicts of Interest Policies and Resources section'. The policy specifically on industry interactions with industry is linked from that Academic Affairs site, or may be viewed directly on the Quality site along with its own FAQs.
To celebrate the importance of faculty serving as mentors for more junior colleagues, the Dean presents awards for mentoring at the SMD Convocation annually.
The call for nominations will go out each year in the fall.
Fall, 2024, Call for NominationsUniversity of Rochester School of Medicine & Dentistry
Nominations for 2025 Academic Mentoring Awards
Please submit nominations by October 1, 2024
Mentoring can be a powerful force in the personal and professional development of an individual. It benefits not only the mentee, but also the mentor and the University. To recognize mentoring as a valuable contribution to the University of Rochester, we will honor individuals who excel in this important endeavor. There are three awards, one for mentoring junior faculty, one for mentoring pre-doctoral trainees and post-doctoral trainees/fellows in basic science research, and one for mentoring residents, fellows, or other clinical trainees in clinical care or clinical research. These awards were presented at the Faculty Celebration.
Characteristics of the Ideal Mentor
(recognizing that no one person may have all of these skills):
Critical traits of the mentor
- Accepts responsibility for being a mentor
- Gives time and is approachable
- Respected, well-established, secure; not threatened by success of a junior person
- Altruistic; able to invest in the success of another’s career
- Objective and insightful; can evaluate new ideas free of bias
- Capable of empathy and caring; respectful of diversity and differences among people; able to appreciate mentee despite possible differences
Role of the mentor
- Role model
- Teacher
- Support and challenge the person being mentored, balancing the two to promote personal and professional development
- Counselor and advisor
- Sponsor, advocate, and ally, including facilitating and helping establish additional skills, collaborators, mentors, and role models, as needed
- Motivates excellence
Knowledge and skills of the mentor
- Understands the science of hypothesis development and testing and how to guide a mentee to what is important scientifically
- Able to listen, critique, and communicate effectively and constructively
- Knowledgeable about different career tracks, stages of a faculty career, markers of development and progress, criteria, and systems for promotion, informal and formal expectations of faculty development
- Knowledgeable about scientific writing, grant writing, choice of grants, choosing journals in which to publish, time management, human resource management/supervision, team management, budgeting, etc.
- Knowledgeable about balancing multiple professional demands, including service to the Division/Department/School/University
Nature of the relationship between mentor and mentee
- Regard for the individual, recognizing the multiple personal and professional roles he or she may be balancing against professional goals
- Fair, honest, respectful, and ethical relationship
- Proactive, with explicit goals, agendas, and timelines
More information, including a list of prior award recipients, may be found on our mentoring page.
Eligibility and Submissions of Nominations:
There will be THREE AWARDS, presented to the University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry faculty members:
- Faculty Academic Mentoring Award – for a faculty member who has mentored one or more junior faculty (Assistant Professor or Senior Instructor).
- Trainee Academic Mentoring Award in Basic Science – for a faculty member who has mentored pre-doctoral trainees and post-doctoral trainees/fellows in basic science research.
- Trainee Academic Mentoring Award in Clinical Programs – for a faculty member who has mentored residents, fellows, or other clinical trainees in clinical care or clinical research.
The nomination process involves 2 sequential steps:
- Initial nominations will consist of:
- A letter of recommendation from the Chair or Unit Director (the letter should summarize the extent and impact of the nominee’s accomplishments as a mentor).
- The nominee’s Curriculum Vitae.
Please do not include additional materials; they will not be considered at this stage of the process.
- The Mentoring Awards Committee will review nominations and select candidates they would like to receive additional information for, in each category. At that time, we will request the Chair of Unit Director provide additional letters of recommendation.
Please combine the application materials into a single pdf with searchable text (i.e., convert Word to pdf rather than scanning hard copies) and deliver by email no later than 6 p.m. October 1, 2024 to: britney_swanger@urmc.rochester.edu
In the subject line of the email, please include the nominee’s name and which award the nomination is for.
Questions regarding the nomination process may be directed to the Office of Academic Affairs at (585) 275-3030 or via email at britney_swanger@urmc.rochester.edu
Recipients of Mentoring Awards 2000 - Present
JAMA Paper on Mentoring